Saturday, November 20, 2004

Final Solution

First of all, to those bloggers who have made me feel somewhat understood, and perhaps a little less cynical – a sincere thank you from the depths of my heart.
____________________________________________________

Final Solution

Went to see Final Solution on Friday evening with boss woman’s husband.

I was very disappointed. To begin with, it’s 148 mins long, that’s 2 hrs and 28 mins. Much too long for a documentary, was my original thought, should be able to say what you need to in an hour, but let’s see it before we judge.

And this is what I saw – a series of eye witness accounts cut with Narendra Modi giving speeches during the Gaurav Yatra, many plates with large amounts of text containing investigative findings, timelines and meanings of words like ‘Gaurav’ and ‘Yatra’.

I think sitting through this film would desensitize even those with anti-fundamentalist sympathies. And sure enough, people started walking out in the middle – I stuck it out for an hour and a half, more out of support for a documentary film maker trying to make a difference than anything else.

What is the point of showing so much footage of the same thing. Okay you show different scenarios – arson, molestation, the Sabarmati Express, but at some point you have to move ahead and talk of solutions and perhaps some historical or political insight.

I think a film like this would have been much more effective had it focused on two or three families with victims instead of a hundred. And you can’t expect an audience to handle large amounts of text containing complex timelines and findings. Why didn’t he use a narrator? Or have characters talking about the incidents/findings?
____________________________________________________

Built a lego house with my sweet niece today.

She is so grown up now, when B came around and started pulling her cheeks, she said ‘Excuse me. That is my mouth and it hurts.’!!

6 Comments:

At 8:50 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Deepak Jeswal here

Saw ur name on a couple of blogs, so came over. Nice, neat and uncluttered- i bet u hv a neat strong sloping handwriting as well!

Your luv for niece is quite similar to what i hv for my naughty nephews!

Do drop in sometime to my blog!

http://randomexpressions.rediffblogs.com

I guess i hv tried to maintain as much as of the original intention of starting it, alongwith playing to the gallery as well;)

 
At 10:26 PM, Blogger Kraz Arkin said...

LEGO is fun. I still remember asking a cuz who called from the states to get me LEGO. Those were days of bad telephone lines and crackling voices. He incredulously asked me - All you want from America are Laddoos?

 
At 12:10 AM, Blogger The Budweiser said...

Is that a film U were talking abt????

 
At 6:39 AM, Blogger cactusjump said...

deepak: actually my handwriting is really really bad! i've been good at things like collages and posters though, but the neatness of this blog's layout goes entirely to the creator of the template. i did have the good sense to choose it though, plus yknow they say einstein had terrible handwriting too - har har!

kraz: yeah, lego is great! especially the bigger sets where you get swings and umbrellas and a huge dog which reaches the second floor of the houses! waiting patiently for some krazesque fact/fiction...

poizon: yes, it's a documentary by rakesh sharma exploring the godhra train incident and the post godhra riots in gujrat. it ties the bjp, rss and vhp with these incidents and so was banned. this was a special screening.

 
At 10:42 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

oye yo uthink too muchh dude .. and stop watcing serious even if you wanna make your boses spouse happy you could get a disease called ,, truly depressed
meet me at twodimensions.rediffblogs.com

 
At 7:33 AM, Blogger cactusjump said...

bhavna @ twodimensions: For the poet -

The mind is its own place, and in itself
Can make a heaven of hell, a hell of heaven.
- Paradise Lost, Milton

Yup, you hit the nail on the head!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home